Liberal migration claims rely on outdated data

Matthew Elmas March 09, 2026
85a2b41c 61da 49d9 9ed7 85cfa930844b
Liberal leader Angus Taylor and deputy Jane Hume have been critical of Labor's record on migration. Image by Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS

WHAT WAS CLAIMED

Around half a million people have come to Australia each year under Labor.

OUR VERDICT

Misleading. While net overseas migration reached 555,800 in 2022/23, it has fallen in the years since.

AAP FACTCHECK - Claims from the Liberal Party's new leadership team that half a million migrants have entered the country each year under Labor are misleading, experts say. 

While net overseas migration - the number of migrants arriving minus those departing - was 555,800 in 2022/23, it has fallen in the years since.

The latest data shows net overseas migration (NOM) was 305,570 in the year to June 2025.

Experts told AAP FactCheck the 2022/23 spike was a rebound following the pandemic, partly driven by changes to visa regulations from the coalition. 

The coalition referenced the 2022/23 figure on numerous occasions during last year's election campaign, when AAP FactCheck debunked similar migration claims.

Immigration has gained a renewed focus following Angus Taylor's appointment as Liberal leader last month.

New deputy leader Jane Hume has claimed that half a million people have come to the country a year under Labor, while Mr Taylor has also referenced the 500,000 figure.

Jane Hume during a shadow ministry announcement in Sydney.
Jane Hume was appointed deputy leader of the opposition in February following a leadership spill. (Bianca De Marchi/AAP PHOTOS)

Senator Hume told the ABC's Insiders program on February 15 that immigration had "run out of control" under Labor (timestamp 12 minutes, 30 seconds).

"We can safely say that over the last few years, we've seen our immigration poorly managed," Senator Hume said.

"Around half a million people coming to the country per year has put pressure on our services, pressure on our health system, pressure on our infrastructure, on our roads, and certainly pressure on housing as well."

Senator Hume separately told Sky News on February 16 that "half a million people coming into this country on an annual basis" had put pressure on infrastructure.

She also told Sky News on February 19 that under Labor "we've seen over half a million people come to our country each year," (timestamp four minutes 50 seconds).

Senator Hume's office didn't respond to AAP FactCheck's request for evidence.

The senator's references to per year and each year suggest her claim relates to migration rates over a number of years, but other senior Liberals appear to reference a single year in relation to the 500,000 figure.

Mr Taylor, for example, claimed during an interview on the ABC's 7.30 program on February 16 that migration rates had been "way too high" and specifically cited NOM. 

"This government allows the NOM - the net overseas migration - to get to over half a million and all they want to do is blame someone else," he said (timestamp 10 minutes 56 seconds).

Leader of the Opposition Angus Taylor during Question Time.
Angus Taylor is expected to release the coalition's immigration policy in the coming weeks. (Mick Tsikas/AAP PHOTOS)

It is unclear whether Senator Hume is referring to NOM or just to arrivals data. 

The latest figures show there were 568,370 arrivals in the year to June 2025, down from a post-pandemic peak of 755,440 in the year to September 2023. 

The latest arrivals total is lower than the level under the coalition government prior to the pandemic, when 607,870 arrived in the year to December 2019. 

However, experts say NOM is the meaningful measure of migration's impact on infrastructure, health and housing, as it captures the net effect of people both entering and leaving the country.

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data shows NOM did peak at 555,800 in the year to September 2023, however in the same period the following year it fell to 364,820, and in the year to June 2025, the latest data, it fell further to 305,570.

Experts say the opposition's claim omits these facts, as well as other key context about why rates rose so sharply after COVID restrictions were lifted to the peak in 2022/23.

For example, this peak occurred following a year of negative NOM while COVID restrictions were in place.

Alan Gamlan, a migration expert at the Australian National University, said when viewed across five years, the annual NOM averaged around 260,000 per year.

"The latest data also show NOM trending downward," Professor Gamlan said. "It's therefore misleading to suggest a consistent annual inflow of half a million over the past five years."

Fethi Mansouri, an expert in migration at Deakin University, told AAP FactCheck that the claims are "erroneous", based on the NOM data from the ABS. 

Former deputy secretary of the government's immigration department Abul Rizvi also told AAP FactCheck that Senator Hume's claim is contrary to the NOM data.

Residential housing in Adelaide.
The coalition claims migration levels are putting pressure on housing and infrastructure. (Dave Hunt/AAP PHOTOS)

Additionally, he said the 2022/23 spike was partly a result of policies in place when Labor came to power in May 2022.

Notably, these policies not only increased the number of arrivals, but also reduced the number of departures - contributing to a higher NOM figure.

In particular, he cited fee-free applications for student and working holiday makers introduced in early 2022; the special COVID visa introduced in 2020 that enabled temporary entrants to extend stays in Australia with full work rights; and an expansion of the working holiday maker scheme in 2022. 

He also said the introduction of unrestricted work rights for students in 2022 effectively made the student visa into an unsponsored work visa.

In a piece for the Independent Australia website, Mr Rizvi said while there is an argument Labor took too long to tighten the policies they inherited, "it was the Coalition that had stomped its foot on the immigration accelerator".

As previously covered, the Albanese government also introduced policies to lift migration in 2022 amid political pressure from the coalition and business groups to address labour shortages after COVID border closures ended. 

Leader of the Opposition Peter Dutton.
Former Opposition Leader Peter Dutton called for an increase in immigration levels in 2022. (Jono Searle/AAP PHOTOS)

Then-coalition leader, Peter Dutton, said in a September 2022 interview: "We do need an increase in the migration numbers.

"We'll see what the government actually delivers because this can be many, many months, if not a couple of years in the pipeline."

The Albanese government extended graduate visas and lifted the permanent migration intake in 2022/23.

AAP FactCheck is an accredited member of the International Fact-Checking Network. To keep up with our latest fact checks, follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, X, BlueSky, TikTok and YouTube.

Sources

Fact-checking is a team effort

Every AAP FactCheck article is the result of a meticulous process involving numerous experienced journalists and producers. Our articles are thoroughly researched, carefully crafted and rigorously scrutinised to ensure the highest standard of accuracy and objectivity in every piece.

AAP FactCheck is an accredited member of the International Fact-Checking Network